• Despite sluggish sector activity, we were encouraged by a 53% YoY increase in AI’s loan advancements. Consequently, mortgage receivables (gross) rose 2% QoQ to $908M – the highest in AI's history.
  • AI’s lending rates have started declining due to the Bank of Canada’s recent rate cuts. With cooling inflation and a softer jobs market, we expect further rate cuts, and a boost in AI’s transaction volumes in H2-2024. 
  • A concern in Q2 was the rise in stage three (impaired) mortgages due to the reclassification of a $50M mortgage from stage two to stage three.  In the earnings call, management stated that they are actively engaging with potential buyers of the collateral, indicating that a liquidation event is potentially on the horizon. We are raising our 2024 loan loss provision estimate by 13% to $17M (H1: $8M).
  • As a result, we are lowering our 2024 dividend forecast by 5% to $1.04/share, reflecting a yield of 9.4%. In our May 2024 report, we predicted a rally in MIC/financial stocks driven by lower rates, and sector multiples have since risen by 6%. We remain bullish on MIC/financial stocks,  and foresee additional rallies in H2-2024 as rate cuts come into effect.

Price and Volume (1-year)

 

  YTD 12M
AI 6% -2%
TSX 6% 10%

 

Portfolio Update

Loan advancements were up 53% YoY; repayments were down 10% YoY .  Net mortgages outstanding were up 2% QoQ to $884M 

 

We believe transaction volumes will pick up in H2-2024, driven by lower interest rates. LTV, duration, the average mortgage size, and exposure to first mortgages remained relatively unchanged QoQ

Lending rates decreased primarily due to the BoC’s rate cut in Q2; we expect this trend will continue over the next 12 months

 

Increased exposure to commercial development projects while scaling back on residential development projects; management is currently focusing on lower-risk property types, such as single-family residential and income-producing commercial properties

Increased exposure to ON. Stage three (impaired) mortgages increased by 244% QoQ to 8% of mortgages, primarily driven by the reclassification of a $50M mortgage on a residential development project in B.C. from stage two to stage three

As a result, management raised loan loss allowances by 41 bps QoQ, to 3.2% of mortgages. We are raising our 2024 loan loss provision estimate by 13% to $17M (H1-2024: $8M)

Overall, we believe the portfolio’s risk profile has increased due to higher stage three mortgages

 

Financials

Q2 revenue was up 6% YoY, amid higher lending rates, aligning with our estimate. However, EPS was down 20% YoY, driven by higher loan loss provisions, missing our estimate by 5%.

Annual regular dividends remained unchanged at $0.90/share. Debt to capital remained within historic levels (40%-45%) 

 

FRC Forecasts 

 

As a result of higher loan loss provisions, we are lowering our 2024 EPS and dividend estimates. 

 

Our estimate for the 2024 dividend varies between $0.67 and $1.42/share, using various YoY increases in loan loss allowances 

 

Comparables Analysis and Valuation

Sector multiples are up 5% since our previous report in May 2024, and 23% below pre-pandemic levels

Our fair value estimate decreased from $13.21 to $13.03/share as we lowered our 2024 EPS and dividend estimates, partially offset by the impact of higher sector multiples

 

We are reiterating our BUY rating, and adjusting our fair value estimate from $13.21 to $13.03/share, implying a potential return of 26% (including dividends) in the next 12 months. Atrium maintains its status as the highest-yielding, and the second largest publicly traded MIC, with a higher percentage of first mortgages, and lower average Loan-to-Value (LTV) mortgages. Key risks include a softer mortgage origination market, and higher default rates. Anticipating lower interest rates, we foresee a potential rally in MIC/financial stocks in H2-2024. Although lower rates can compress profit margins, the resulting economic boost, and potential for higher valuations, will likely have a more significant positive impact. 

 

Risks

Maintaining our risk rating of 3 (Average)

We believe the company is exposed to the following risks: 

  • Diversification – over 70% of Atrium's mortgages are secured by properties in ON 
  • Credit 
  • A downturn in the real estate sector may impact the company’s deal flow 
  • Timely deployment of capital is critical
  • Investments in mortgages are typically affected by macroeconomic conditions, and local real estate markets
  • Highly competitive sector 
  • Like most MICs, the company uses leverage to fund mortgages
  • Default rates can rise during recession

 

APPENDIX